Contributors: (ordered alphabetically) Arthit Suriyawongkul(ADAPT Centre, Trinity College Dublin),
Beatriz Esteves(IDLab, IMEC, Ghent University),
Harshvardhan J. Pandit(AI Accountability Lab (AIAL), Trinity College Dublin).
NOTE: The affiliations are informative, do not represent formal endorsements, and may be outdated as this list is generated automatically from existing data.
This extension provides concepts to support implementations of the EU Health Data Space ([[EHDS]]) regulation by providing concepts and methods for implementing the regulation, as well as to support its alignment with other regulations such as GDPR, DGA, and AI Act.
NOTE: This is a draft vocabulary, which is being updated as the EHDS text is published and formally recognised as a regulation. Currently, for the next release we are working on concepts related to entities, e.g., manufacturers of EHR systems and digital health authorities, data categories, e.g., electronic health data, purposes, e.g., healthcare service provision, technologies, e.g., EHR systems or wellness applications, rights, e.g., of natural persons, and organisational measures, e.g., data requests and activity reports. The DPVCG welcomes participation and contributions for this work.
DPV Specifications: The [[DPV]] is the core specification that is extended by specific extensions. A [[PRIMER]] introduces the concepts and modelling of DPV specifications, and [[GUIDES]] describe application of DPV for specific applications and use-cases. The Search Index page provides a searchable hierarchy of all concepts. The Data Privacy Vocabularies and Controls Community Group (DPVCG) develops and manages these specifications through GitHub. For meetings, see the DPVCG calendar.
Contributing: The DPVCG welcomes participation to improve the DPV and associated resources, including expansion or refinement of concepts, requesting information and applications, and addressing open issues. See contributing guide for further information.
Introduction
The [[EHDS]] is an upcoming regulation that establishes a data space for the sharing and reuse of 'health data'. The regulation is expected to be published in 2025, and will outline the specific framework and obligations for implementing the health data space(s). The document establishing an agreed text between the EU's law-making bodies can be found in the associated press release (direct link to PDF). While the final text will contain revisions, the intent and implementing aspects of the regulation can be expected to be the same.
The implementation of the [[EHDS]] is of great interest due to its potential for unlocking and expanding the use of data currently stored in various health institutions, and to use this for progressive scientific research that will enhance healthcare and benefit society. For this, the HealthData@EU Pilot is a pilot project that is building the infrastructure for implementing the [[EHDS]]. It is creating the [[[HealthDCAT-AP]]] specification, which expands the well-adopted DCAT-AP specification for specifying metadata and catalogues of health datasets, which can then be accessed and reused via a common portal.
The [[HealthDCAT-AP]]'s specification reuses [[DPV]] concepts and properties to represent information about personal data, legal bases, purpose, and jurisdiction. See the note on DPVCG mailing list for more details. The aim of this extension is thus to support implementations like [[HealthDCAT-AP]] by providing a specific vocabulary that extends [[DPV]] concepts to represent the categories of personal data, legal bases, purposes, technical and organisational measures, and other processes and artefacts that are necessary to implement and support the [[EHDS]]. In this, we seek to work closely with efforts such as the HealthData@EU to avoid duplication of efforts and to develop a consistent and useful solution for stakeholders.
The rest of the document describes a draft vocabulary that was developed based on the initial documents of the [[EHDS]], and which shows how the concepts from the regulation can be modelled within the framework of [[DPV]] specifications to enable implementing the requirements of the [[EHDS]]. As the state of the [[EHDS]] regulation progresses towards a formal publication and then real-world implementation, the DPVCG will be updating this vocabulary with more concepts and guidance to support use-cases.
Data
This section contains concepts representing the categories of data described in the EHDS. The EHDS defines 'electronic health data', which encompasses both personal and non-personal electronic health data. Furthermore, Article 14 defines priority categories of personal electronic health data for primary use, and Article 51 establishes the minimum categories of electronic health data for secondary use. In the next iteration of this extension, the categories of Article 14 and 51 will be aligned with the [[EHDS]] concepts of personal and non-personal electronic health data.
In future iterations, the DPVCG is interested in further refining this vocabulary by aligning the concepts with those from [[DPV]] - in particular to establish personal data that are sensitive, and personal data that are classified as special category for use with the [[EU-GDPR]] extension. The DPVCG is also interested to align and enhance the categories of personal data with the [[PD]] extension, and the [[SECTOR-HEALTH]] sectorial extension which models generic healthcare concepts.
eu-ehds:BehaviouralHealthDeterminant: Information about behavioural data impacting on health
go to full definition
eu-ehds:BiobankData: Information about electronic health data from biobanks and associated databases
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ClaimAdminData: Information about health-related administrative data on claims
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ClinicalInvestigationsData: Information about health data from clinical investigations
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ClinicalStudiesData: Information about health data from clinical studies
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ClinicalTrialsData: Information about health data from clinical trials
go to full definition
eu-ehds:DiseaseRegistryData: Information about electronic health data from medical registries for specific diseases
go to full definition
eu-ehds:DispensationAdminData: Information about health-related administrative data on dispensations
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EHR: Electronic health record (EHR) means a collection of electronic health data related to a natural person and collected in the health system, processed for the purpose of the provision of healthcare
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EHRData: Information about data from electronic health records
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ElectronicDispensation: Information about electronic dispensations
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ElectronicHealthData: Information about electronic health data, including personal and non-personal data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ElectronicPrescription: Information about electronic prescriptions
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EnvironmentalHealthDeterminant: Information about environmental data impacting on health
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthAdminData: Information about health-related administrative data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthcareFinancingAggregatedData: Information about aggregated data on healthcare expenditure and financing
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthcareNeedsAggregatedData: Information about aggregated data on healthcare needs
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthcareProvisionAggregatedData: Information about aggregated data on the provision of and access to healthcare
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthcareResourcesAggregatedData: Information about aggregated data on resources allocated to healthcare
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthProfessionalData: Information about the status of the health professionals involved in the treatment of the person, including information on their specialisation and institution
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthQuestionnaire: Information about health data from questionnaires
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthSurvey: Information about health data from surveys
go to full definition
eu-ehds:InferredHealthData: Information about inferred health data, including improvements such as correction, annotation, or enrichment based on authorised processing operations
go to full definition
eu-ehds:MortalityRegistryData: Information about electronic health data from mortality registries
go to full definition
eu-ehds:NonPersonalElectronicHealthData: Information about electronic health data that is not personal data, including anonymised data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PathogenData: Information about relevant pathogen data, impacting on human health
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PerformanceStudiesData: Information about health data from performance studies
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PersonalElectronicHealthData: Information about personal health data, including genetic data, processed in an electronic form
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PersonGeneratedMedicalDeviceData: Information about person generated medical devices data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PersonGeneratedWellnessAppData: Information about person generated wellness applications data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PublicHealthRegistryData: Information about registries of public health data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ReimbursementAdminData: Information about health-related administrative data on reimbursements
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ResearchCohortData: Information about health data from research cohorts
go to full definition
eu-ehds:SocioeconomicHealthDeterminant: Information about socioeconomic data impacting on health
go to full definition
eu-ehds:TranscriptomicData: Information about transcriptomic data
go to full definition
Entities
This section contains concepts representing the categories and roles of legal entities described in the EHDS. In future iterations, the DPVCG is interested in further refining this vocabulary by aligning the concepts with those from [[DPV]] - in particular to establish entities that are non-commercial or non-profit in nature, or are research organisations, as well as to represent commonly occurring entity categories such as hospitals, clinics, and other relevant concepts in alignment with the [[SECTOR-HEALTH]] sectorial extension which models generic healthcare concepts.
eu-ehds:AuthorisedRepresentative: Legal representative established in the EU of a manufacturer of an EHR system established outside of the EU
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EHDSBoard: An authority tasked with facilitating the cooperation and the exchange of information among Member States and the Commission for primary and secondary use
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthDataAccessBody: An entity governed by public law responsible for granting access to electronic health data for secondary use
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthDataHolder: An entity in the healthcare sector who has the right to process personal electronic health data or make available non-personal electronic health data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:TrustedHealthDataHolder: A health data holder that meets the conditions for the simplified procedure to access electronic health data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthDataUser: An entity in the healthcare sector who was granted access to electronic health data for secondary use
go to full definition
Purposes
This section contains concepts representing the categories of purposes described in the EHDS. Article 2.2(d) defines purposes for the processing of electronic health data for primary use, while Article 53 establishes the purposes for which electronic health data can be processed for secondary use. The DPVCG is interested in providing guidance on how to use these concepts to express primary and secondary use scenarios.
In future iterations, the DPVCG is interested in further refining this vocabulary by aligning the concepts with those from [[DPV]] - in particular to establish purposes that can be considered as relevant to the provision of healthcare, or for public benefit, or are necessary for medical research. The DPVCG is also interested to align and enhance the categories of purposes with the [[SECTOR-HEALTH]] sectorial extension which models generic healthcare concepts.
eu-ehds:AdministrativeServicesProvision: Purposes associated with the provision of administrative services related to healthcare
go to full definition
eu-ehds:DevelopPublicHealthProductsAndServices: Purposes associated with developing products and services that contribute to public health
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EnsureQualitySafetyHealthcare: Purposes associated with ensuring high levels of quality and safety of healthcare, including patients safety
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EnsureQualitySafetyMedicalDevices: Purposes associated with ensuring high levels of quality and safety of medical devices
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EnsureQualitySafetyMedicinalProducts: Purposes associated with ensuring high levels of quality and safety of medicinal products
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthcareScientificResearch: Purposes associated with healthcare scientific research
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ImproveHealthcare: Purposes associated with improving healthcare systems, including the delivery of care and the provision and optimisation of treatment
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ImproveHealthcareEducation: Purposes associated with improving the provision of healthcare education
go to full definition
eu-ehds:MedicalDevicesDispensation: Purposes associated with the dispensation of medical devices
go to full definition
eu-ehds:MedicalDevicesPrescription: Purposes associated with prescription of medical devices
go to full definition
eu-ehds:MedicalDevicesProvision: Purposes associated with the provision of medical devices
go to full definition
eu-ehds:MedicinalProductsDispensation: Purposes associated with the dispensation of medicinal products
go to full definition
eu-ehds:MedicinalProductsPrescription: Purposes associated with prescription of medicinal products
go to full definition
eu-ehds:MedicinalProductsProvision: Purposes associated with the provision of medicinal products
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ProtectAgainstCrossBorderThreatsToHealth: Purposes associated with the protection against serious cross-border threats to health
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ProvideHealthcareOfficialStatistics: Purposes associated with facilitating the development, production and dissemination of reliable official statistics related to health or care sectors
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PublicHealthSurveillance: Purposes associated with public health surveillance
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PublicInterestRelatedToHealth: Purposes associated with pursuing activities for reasons of public interest in the area of public and occupational health
go to full definition
eu-ehds:PublicPolicyMaking: Purposes associated with public policy making policymaking in the healthcare sector
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ReimbursementServicesProvision: Purposes associated with the provision of reimbursement services related to healthcare
go to full definition
eu-ehds:SocialServicesProvision: Purposes associated with the provision of social services related to healthcare
go to full definition
eu-ehds:SupportAuthoritiesRegulatoryActivities: Purposes associated with supporting authorities to carry out their regulatory tasks
go to full definition
eu-ehds:TrainTestAndEvaluateAISystemsAlgorithms: Purposes associated with training, testing and evaluating algorithms in AI systems
go to full definition
eu-ehds:TrainTestAndEvaluateHealthAlgorithms: Purposes associated with training, testing and evaluating health-related algorithms
go to full definition
eu-ehds:TrainTestAndEvaluateHealthAppsAlgorithms: Purposes associated with training, testing and evaluating algorithms in digital health applications
go to full definition
eu-ehds:TrainTestAndEvaluateMedicalDevicesAlgorithms: Purposes associated with training, testing and evaluating algorithms in medical devices
go to full definition
Processes
This section contains miscellaneous concepts that can be considered as processes under the EHDS. These will be changed in future versions of the extension. The current concepts of 'health data request' and 'data permit' represent the mechanisms through which data is to be requested and through which it will be permitted to be used. The DPVCG is interested in modelling these in terms of specific activities - including how to request, how to express information in a request, lifecycle of a request (e.g., request made, being considered, accepted, or refused), and the accompanying assessments (request validity, risk/impact assessment), and documentation (request log, request report). Likewise, the use of data will also require specific concepts that model such specific processes and artefacts. Further, the DPVCG is interested in establishing specific legal bases and mechanisms that are crucial for the implementation of the EHDS, including its alignment with other extensions implementing regulations such as [[EU-GDPR]] and [[EU-DGA]].
eu-ehds:DataPermit: Permit issued by health data access bodies to health data applicants regarding health data access applications
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthDataAccessApplication: Application sent by a natural or legal person to health data access bodies, seeking access to electronic health data for secondary use
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthDataRequest: Request sent by health data applicants to health data access bodies, seeking access to statistically anonymised electronic health data for secondary use
go to full definition
Technologies
This section contains concepts regarding the technologies mentioned in the EHDS regulation, namely related to EHR systems, wellness applications, and data access services. These will be changed in future versions of the extension. Concepts related to technologies are also provided in [[TECH]] (generic) and [[SECTOR-HEALTH]] (health-specific).
eu-ehds:EHRSystem: A system whereby the software and/or hardware allows personal electronic health data to be collected and processed, to be used by healthcare providers when providing patient care or by patients when accessing their electronic health data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:ElectronicHealthDataAccessService: Technical service, such as an online portal or application, that allows data subjects to access their electronic health data or the electronic health data of those natural persons whose electronic health data they are legally authorised to access
go to full definition
eu-ehds:HealthProfessionalAccessService: Technical service, supported by an EHR system, that enables health professionals to access data of natural persons under their care
go to full definition
eu-ehds:InteroperabilitySoftwareForEHRSystem: Software component of the EHR system which provides and receives personal electronic health data under a priority category for primary use established under the EHDS Regulation in the European electronic health record exchange format
go to full definition
eu-ehds:LoggingSoftwareForEHRSystem: Software component of the EHR system which provides logging information related to access by health professionals or other individuals to priority categories of personal electronic health data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:WellnessApplication: Software component for the processing of electronic health data, specifically for providing information on the health of natural persons, or the delivery of care for purposes other than the provision of healthcare
go to full definition
Rights
This section provides concepts representing several rights to natural and legal persons whose applicability depends on the context and nature of processing taking place. In addition to these concepts, the DPVCG is interested in providing additional concepts, e.g., impacts on rights and justifications, and documentation related to the exercising and management of these rights. Furthermore, the DPVCG is interested in the alignment of these rights with rights from other extensions implementing regulations such as the [[EU-GDPR]] and [[EU-DGA]].
eu-ehds:A10: Right of natural persons to opt out from the access to their personal electronic health data registered in an EHR system through the electronic health data access services
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A100: Right of natural and legal persons to receive compensation in accordance with EU and national law in case that they have suffered material or non-material damage as a result of an infringement of the EHDS Regulation
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A16-1: Right of natural persons to identify themselves electronically using any electronic identification means which are recognised pursuant to Article 6 of Regulation (EU) No 910/2014
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A21: Right of natural and legal persons to lodge a complaint with the competent digital health authority
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A3: Right of natural persons to access personal electronic health data relating to them that belong to the priority categories referred to in Article 14 and are processed for the provision of healthcare through the electronic health data access services referred to in Article 4
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A5: Right of natural persons to insert information in their EHR through electronic health data access services or applications linked to those services
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A6: Right of natural persons to request online the rectification of their personal electronic health data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A68-11: Right of health data users to access and process the electronic health data in a secure processing environment in accordance with the data permit issued to them
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A7: Right of natural persons to give access to, or to request a healthcare provider to transmit, all or part of their personal electronic health data to another healthcare provider of their choice
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A71: Right of natural persons to opt out at any time, and without providing any reason, from the processing of personal electronic health data relating to them for secondary use
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A8: Right of natural persons to restrict the access of health professionals and healthcare providers to all or parts of their personal electronic health data
go to full definition
eu-ehds:A9: Right of natural persons to obtain information, including through automatic notifications, on any access to their personal electronic health data through the health professional access service obtained in the context of healthcare
go to full definition
Tech/Org Measures
This section contains concepts regarding the technical and organisational measures mentioned in the EHDS regulation. These will be changed in future versions of the extension. Concepts are also provided in [[DPV]] (generic) and [[SECTOR-HEALTH]] (health-specific). In this context, the DPVCG is interested in providing guidelines on how to express information related to activities reported by a digital health authority, documentation of EHR systems or databases of EHR systems and wellness applications.
eu-ehds:DigitalHealthAuthorityActivityReport: Document containing an overview of activities reported by a digital health authority
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EHRSystemInformationSheet: Technical documentation with information related to the EHR system, including its manufacturer, intended purpose and supported standards
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EHRSystemTechnicalDocumentation: Technical documentation that demonstrates that the EHR system manufacturers comply with the requirements laid down in Annex II
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EUDatabaseForRegistrationOfEHRSystems: Publicly available database established by the European Commission to maintain data on EHR systems for which an EU declaration of conformity has been issued according to EHDS Article 39
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EUDatabaseForRegistrationOfWellnessApplications: Publicly available database established by the European Commission to maintain data on wellness applications for which a label has been issued pursuant to EHDS Article 47
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EUDeclarationOfConformity: Declaration of conformity by the EU stating that the manufacturer of an EHR system has demonstrated that the essential requirements laid down in EHDS Annex II have been fulfilled
go to full definition
eu-ehds:EuropeanDigitalTestingEnvironment: Data processing environment for the assessment of harmonised software components of EHR systems
go to full definition
eu-ehds:WellnessApplicationLabel: Label issued by the manufacturer of the wellness application that indicating its compliance with the common specifications referred to in EHDS Article 36 and the requirements laid down in EHDS Annex II
go to full definition
Vocabulary Index
Classes
A10 Right of natural persons to opt out from primary use
Term
A10
Prefix
eu-ehds
Label
A10 Right of natural persons to opt out from primary use
Right of natural persons to opt out from the access to their personal electronic health data registered in an EHR system through the electronic health data access services
Right of natural and legal persons to receive compensation in accordance with EU and national law in case that they have suffered material or non-material damage as a result of an infringement of the EHDS Regulation
Right of natural persons to identify themselves electronically using any electronic identification means which are recognised pursuant to Article 6 of Regulation (EU) No 910/2014
Right of natural persons to access personal electronic health data relating to them that belong to the priority categories referred to in Article 14 and are processed for the provision of healthcare through the electronic health data access services referred to in Article 4
Right of health data users to access and process the electronic health data in a secure processing environment in accordance with the data permit issued to them
Right of natural persons to give access to, or to request a healthcare provider to transmit, all or part of their personal electronic health data to another healthcare provider of their choice
Right of natural persons to opt out at any time, and without providing any reason, from the processing of personal electronic health data relating to them for secondary use
Right of natural persons to restrict the access of health professionals and healthcare providers to all or parts of their personal electronic health data
Right of natural persons to obtain information, including through automatic notifications, on any access to their personal electronic health data through the health professional access service obtained in the context of healthcare
An authority tasked with facilitating the cooperation and the exchange of information among Member States and the Commission for primary and secondary use
Electronic health record (EHR) means a collection of electronic health data related to a natural person and collected in the health system, processed for the purpose of the provision of healthcare
Usage Note
This concept represents the EHR itself with EHRData referring to data within it
A system whereby the software and/or hardware allows personal electronic health data to be collected and processed, to be used by healthcare providers when providing patient care or by patients when accessing their electronic health data
Technical service, such as an online portal or application, that allows data subjects to access their electronic health data or the electronic health data of those natural persons whose electronic health data they are legally authorised to access
Publicly available database established by the European Commission to maintain data on EHR systems for which an EU declaration of conformity has been issued according to EHDS Article 39
Publicly available database established by the European Commission to maintain data on wellness applications for which a label has been issued pursuant to EHDS Article 47
Declaration of conformity by the EU stating that the manufacturer of an EHR system has demonstrated that the essential requirements laid down in EHDS Annex II have been fulfilled
Request sent by health data applicants to health data access bodies, seeking access to statistically anonymised electronic health data for secondary use
Information about the status of the health professionals involved in the treatment of the person, including information on their specialisation and institution
Software component of the EHR system which provides and receives personal electronic health data under a priority category for primary use established under the EHDS Regulation in the European electronic health record exchange format
Software component of the EHR system which provides logging information related to access by health professionals or other individuals to priority categories of personal electronic health data
Software component for the processing of electronic health data, specifically for providing information on the health of natural persons, or the delivery of care for purposes other than the provision of healthcare
Label issued by the manufacturer of the wellness application that indicating its compliance with the common specifications referred to in EHDS Article 36 and the requirements laid down in EHDS Annex II
The following external concepts are re-used within DPV:
External
Funding Acknowledgements
Funding Sponsors
The DPVCG was established as part of the SPECIAL H2020 Project, which received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No. 731601 from 2017 to 2019. Continued developments have been funded under: RECITALS Project funded under the EU's Horizon program with grant agreement No. 101168490.
Harshvardhan J. Pandit was funded to work on DPV from 2020 to 2022 by the Irish Research Council's Government of Ireland Postdoctoral Fellowship Grant#GOIPD/2020/790.
The ADAPT SFI Centre for Digital Media Technology is funded by Science Foundation Ireland through the SFI Research Centres Programme and is co-funded under the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF) through Grant#13/RC/2106 (2018 to 2020) and Grant#13/RC/2106_P2 (2021 onwards).
Funding Acknowledgements for Contributors
The contributions of Beatriz Esteves have received funding through the PROTECT ITN Project from the the INESData project - Infrastructure to Investigate Data Spaces in Distributed Environments at UPM, (TSI-063100-2022-0001), a project funded under the UNICO I+D CLOUD call by the Ministry for Digital Transformation and the Civil Service, in the framework of the recovery plan PRTR financed by the European Union (NextGenerationEU); and from SolidLab Vlaanderen (Flemish Government, EWI and RRF project VV023/10), and by the imec.icon project PACSOI (HBC.2023.0752) which was co-financed by imec and VLAIO; and the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No 813497; and the SolidLab Vlaanderen (Flemish Government, EWI and RRF project VV023/10), and by the imec.icon project PACSOI (HBC.2023.0752) which was co-financed by imec and VLAIO.
The contributions of Julian Flake have received funding from the TITAN project funded under European Union’s Horizon Europe Framework Programme grant#101129822 and from the European Union’s Digital Europe Programme grant#101123471 (EDGE-Skills).
The contributions of Harshvardhan J. Pandit have been made with the financial support of Science Foundation Ireland under Grant Agreement No. 13/RC/2106_P2 at the ADAPT SFI Research Centre; and the AI Accountability Lab (AIAL) which is supported by grants from following groups: the AI Collaborative, an Initiative of the Omidyar Group; Luminate; the Bestseller Foundation; and the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation.